COVID-19 : WE ARE OPEN! If you need to visit our offices, please practice 6 feet social distancing at all times.  We continue to encourage safe practices and ask all of our customers to make an effort to conduct their insurance business as much as possible either online, by phone, or email.  The Customer Service tab on our website provides convenient ways to pay your bill or make a claim directly with your insurance company. If you need to talk with one of our staff, please call us at 617-268-1566 or email us at  Also, if you need to drop off anything, please utilize the drop-box outside of our front door, we check it everyday.

Thank you in advance for your patience and prudence in this extraordinary time.

What Our Customers Say

I love coming into the office and seeing a familiar face. You are always helpful and answer all my questions.
Richie C.
Wow! I can’t believe how much money I just saved!!!
Tommy P.
I feel like I’m your only customer. Always so accommodating!
Lucy L.
Thanks for entertaining my son while I spoke with Bridget. It made a huge difference!
Ashley G.
I really appreciate your help with that accident. Not sure I would have known what to do without your help.
John W.
I would definitely recommend you to my friends. You guys are good.
Pat D.
I don’t know what I would do without you girls!
Shirley D.

Peace of mind happens when I talk to you guys…

Katherin C.

Hey Tom. I want to send Bridget a gift certificate…she saved me 100 times…she’s the best.

Bill D.

I’ve been a customer of Baltic Insurance Agency for years now. Laura is always looking out for the best price for me!!

Kathy A.

We have been using Kiley and O’Toole for a very long time and I can honestly say they are the best!

George N.

This agency has wonderful agents that are caring and very knowledgeable. They do their best providing the information needed. Nice clean place. Very well organized.

Joseph A.

I’ve been a customer of Baltic Insurance Agency for years now. Laura is always looking out for the best price for me!!

Kathy A.

“great service”.

Susan F.

Why Kiley & O’Toole

  • Convenience & Response:  We have convenient local offices in South Boston & Weymouth and responsive, in-person Customer Service when you need it or want it. Drop in and say hello!
  • Choice & Value:  As independent agents we represent multiple quality insurance companies, not just one.  So we can offer you choice, and the value of true price comparison and more options to fit your insurance needs.
  • Knowledge & Trust:  We are a family-owned and community business since 1985, and have more than 30 years of insurance experience that can be put to work for you. We believe in honesty, transparency and simply taking care of our customers.

Insurance Companies We Represent